The Myth of Certainty: Why Not Knowing Can Set You Free

anxiety management Sep 21, 2025
Overthink No More
The Myth of Certainty: Why Not Knowing Can Set You Free
34:47
 

We live in a world that worships certainty. From financial forecasts to health trackers to five-year plans, we’re told that if we can just know enough, plan enough, or control enough, life will feel safe.

But here’s the truth: certainty is a myth. Life is unpredictable by nature, and the more we chase total security, the more anxious we become. The paradox is that trying to eliminate uncertainty only magnifies it in our minds.

When you think about it, most of our biggest life experiences—falling in love, starting a new job, moving to a new place—began in uncertainty. The unknown isn’t just chaos; it’s also possibility.

Why the Quest for Certainty Fuels Anxiety

Anxiety thrives on the unknown. The mind says, “If I could just be 100% sure, I’d finally relax.” So we double-check, seek reassurance, and imagine every worst-case scenario. But certainty never comes, at least not in the way we demand.

Instead of calming us, the chase for answers keeps our nervous system on high alert. We scan for danger, but what we really need is trust—trust that we can face life even when we don’t know the ending.

Reframing the Unknown

What if uncertainty wasn’t a problem to solve, but a path to walk?

  • Uncertainty means growth. Every new skill or relationship starts with not knowing.

  • Uncertainty means possibility. The fact that you can’t predict the future also means you can’t rule out something wonderful.

  • Uncertainty builds resilience. Each time you face it, you prove to yourself that you can.

The unknown isn’t the enemy. It is the path.

A Practical Way Forward

When anxiety pulls you into the trap of certainty—“What if this happens? What if I can’t handle it?”—try this exercise:

  1. Pause and name it. Say to yourself: “I’m looking for certainty again.”

  2. Breathe into the moment. Notice one thing you can see, hear, and feel right now. Bring your body back to the present.

  3. Shift the question. Instead of “How can I be sure?” ask “What’s my next step?”

You don’t need all the answers to keep moving. You only need enough courage to take the next step.

Closing Thought

Certainty is comforting, but it’s also an illusion. Life’s richness comes from walking forward in faith, even when the road is foggy. The more you practice letting go of the myth of certainty, the more freedom you’ll find—not because the unknown goes away, but because you’ve learned you can walk with it.

 

JOIN THE NEWSLETTER

Practical relief for anxious minds

Includes the free guide: “3 Mistakes That Keep You Anxious.”

You're safe with me. I'll never spam you or sell your contact info.